Tuesday, June 11, 2013

The Deck Finishing Follies

So.  We've been in this house for a little under five years.  And we have a wooden deck that we have ignored.  It wasn't on purpose, but simply because other things took more precedence.  The basement flooding?  Check.  Realizing that after waterproofing, we still needed a second sump pump pit?  Check.  Fixing up the dining room in time for us to host Thanksgiving dinner?  Check.   And so on.  The previous owners did the minimal amount of upkeep over their twenty years here and we've been trying to play catch up ever since we've moved in.

Basically, the deck was pretty low on our list.  Until this spring.  After the past winter, one of our floorboards is rotting away.  So, like any other young couple with not a whole lot of money, we trudged down to the big box stores to buy a replacement board.  I guess we shouldn't have been surprised to discover that apparently our wonderful previous owners hadn't used standard sized wood on the deck! 
What were they thinking when they did this? 
 
 Did they use the 5/4 deck boards?  No.  Did they use 2x6s?  No.  Many an employee scratched their head and tried to guess at the size.  Apparently our boards are much more narrow that what's sold today.  Which in itself is not that big of a problem.  The hubby could always use a saw and cut it to size.

What turned out to be a problem is the DEPTH.  Our deck boards were THICKER than those on the market today.  Meaning anything we replaced it with would sit much lower than the other boards.  If it had been one board, we might have tackled it by buying a custom piece milled to our specs.  But being that we were looking at replacing at least four boards, and possible more?  And this after my husband would have had to hand sand the ugly paint that the previous owners had slopped on?  We decided to use the existing structure, and just replace the deck boards. 

Which then led to more questions...  Do we use pressure treated?  Do we use Cedar?  If we stretch the wallet and go for composite, is it truly maintenance free?  For someone with ADD?  Telling them  to research the "best" option is like sending a diabetic into a candy  store.  I turned to the Internet and google became my friend.  I found a great forum that discusses everything you never wanted to know about decks and patios.  I became obsessed with picking something that would last and wouldn't bankrupt us. 

And the details that we had not thought of were added to my 'research' list!  What wood won't be scratched by dog's claws?  (not many).  Did you know that Pressure treated wood used to have toxic chemicals in them that would literally eat away at nails and screws?  In fact, they still do, but it's not AS bad as it used to be.  Apparently today's PT wood only takes FIVE years to rot a nail, as opposed to the five months it took twenty years ago.  Did you know that the wood used years ago for decks was 'old growth' wood, and what you can buy today is 'new growth' wood, which isn't as durable?

After learning far more than I ever wanted to regarding lumber choices, I moved on to deck décor.  Did we want to lay the wood perpendicular or parallel to the house?  (perpendicular  is our only  option due to the joists.) Did we want to put up new railings or use lower deck bench seating in lue of railings?  Do we use contrasting colors?  Do the deck benches get attached to the joist, railing or do we make one to be freestanding?  And so on.

How did replacing our ONE deck board turn into a deck renovation?  And why is it that most of our projects turn out to be much more elaborate than what we had planned?  I'm off to Pinterest to seek out yet more ideas on deck benches... 

 

No comments:

Post a Comment